Penalty can’t be levied for Rejection of Bonafide Claim: Bombay High Court [Read Order]

IIncome Tax Department - Bombay High Court - Taxscan

The division bench of the Bombay High Court has held that penalty cannot be levied under the Income Tax merely on the ground that a deduction claim was rejected by the department.

The assessee is a Co-operative Bank. For the relevant A.Y under consideration, the assessee had incurred expenditure for acquisition of three co-operative Banks. Claiming directives of RBI contained in its circular, the bank amortized such expenditure over a span of five years.

While completing the assessment proceedings, the Assessing Officer observed that the expenditure was capital in nature and that the claim of expenditure would be governed by the Income Tax Act and not by the directives of RBI. The expenditure was therefore disallowed. In addition, the AO also instituted penalty proceedings and eventually imposed the penalty.

On appeal, the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal deleted the penalty and held that in relation to the assessee’s claim of expenditure, two views were possible.

The two-judge bench comprising Justice Akil Kureshi and Justice S J Kathawalla observed that “Having heard learned counsel for the parties and having perused documents on record, we see no error in the view of the Tribunal. The Tribunal recorded that in relation to the assessee’s claim of expenditure two views were possible. Even otherwise the revenue has not made out any case of concealment of income or concealment of particulars of any income. As is well laid down through a series of judgments of Supreme Court, merely raising a bonafide claim even if ultimately found to be not sustainable is not a ground for imposition of penalty. In the result, Income Tax Appeal is dismissed,” the Tribunal said.

Subscribe Taxscan Premium to view the Judgment
taxscan-loader