Understanding Windfall Taxes

A windfall tax is a higher tax rate levied by governments against certain industries when economic conditions allow those industries to experience above-average profits. The term “Windfall Tax” refers to a one-time tax imposed on businesses that are thought to have made excessively high profits, typically due to unusually favourable market conditions. Windfall taxes are primarily levied on companies in the targeted industry that have benefited the most from the economic windfall, most often commodity-based businesses.

The profits cannot be attributed to something the company was actively involved in, like its business expansion or strategy. Hence, when industries experience massive growth in their income due to external incidents that they are not responsible for, a Windfall Tax is levied on their earnings.

A windfall tax is a higher tax rate on profits that ensue from a sudden windfall gain to a particular company or industry. Following the 2021–2023 global energy crisis, policy specialists at the International Monetary Fund recommended that governments institute windfall profits taxes targeted at economic rents in the energy sector, excluding renewable energy to prevent hindering its further development.

The windfall tax imposed by the government can be in various forms:

• Financial gain- Sometimes the corporations or individuals gets benefit from some kind of windfall gain which leads to a huge financial gain. In such cases the entity or individual will have to pay the tax.
• Gains are obtained from many countries from natural resources such as oil or minerals. This happens when suddenly the commodity prices rise. But such profits should be energy windfall tax.
• The governments of some countries levy tax on gain from rise in property values, in cases where the property is owned by the corporation or individuals.

Purpose

Windfall taxes is related to individual and non-corporate entities when there is a surge in the income levels by receiving a large corpus of wealth from gifts, inheritance, the game of chance, gambling, or lottery winnings. In many cases, inheritance, gifts from friends or relatives are tax exempt in the hands of the recipient. However, central or regional taxes may be levied on the giver of such inheritance. Income from winnings from lottery and gambling is charged to tax either in the hands of the recipient or the giver of such income.

Windfall taxes are levied with the objective of tax companies to bring down the general price levels of goods and services so that it benefits the end consumer.

Keeping in view of all tax schemes proposed and implemented by the government, there lies a rift between those that are for and against the tax schemes. The merit of a windfall tax rate is that the governments can use the taxed funds to maintain the state of the economy and fight several glaring social causes.

Windfall taxes provide a good source of revenue to the government as it follows the principle that those who have earned a surplus through windfalls to be taxed and also discouraging businesses of the lottery, gambling, horse racing, etc. 

Implementing windfall taxes on crude oil can have positive and negative effects on prices. Such taxes can help regulate and stabilise prices by curbing excessive profits, ensuring consumer affordability. On the other the implementation of the windfall taxes may discourage investments and lead to reduced production, potentially causing a supply shortage and further driving up prices.

Windfall taxes are primarily aimed at generating additional revenue for the government. Moreover, windfall taxes contribute to the country’s overall economic well-being by ensuring a fair distribution of wealth and fostering long-term economic growth.

Windfall tax and India

India first imposed windfall profit taxes on July 1, 2022, joining a host of nations that tax extraordinary profits arising for the energy companies.

After July 1, these refiners received incentives to market their products to domestic oil marketing companies for bulk or retail sales. As a result, OMCs were relieved because they could purchase oil from Reliance and other companies at a lower price without paying the excise duty.

Earlier on April, the centre raised the windfall tax on petroleum crude to 9,600 rupees per ton from Rs 6,800, after firming of crude oil prices in the international market. In the beginning of May, the centre had revised windfall tax on domestically produced crude oil to Rs 8,400 per tonne, down from Rs 9,600 per tonne.

The Central Government in May this year slashed windfall gains tax on domestically produced crude to Rs 5,700 per tonne from earlier Rs 8,400 per tonne. A notification by the CBDT suggested that the new rates for the windfall taxes would be effective from May 16 2024.

The Central Government has lowered the windfall tax on petroleum crude, from Rs. 9,600 to Rs. 8400 per tonne, effective from May 1st, 2024. The tax was lowered by Rs. 1200. Earlier, the government has raised the windfall tax on petroleum crude from Rs. 6,800 to Rs. 9,600 per tonne. With effect from April 4, 2024, to 30th April, the petroleum crude witnessed a raise in windfall tax of Rs. 4,700. This adjustment superseded the prior notification issued on April 15, 2024, as outlined in notification no. 13/2024 – Central Excise, dated 30th April, 2024.

Read More on: Govt lowers Windfall Tax on Petroleum Crude by Rs. 2,700 per Tonne

Govt lowers Windfall Tax on Petroleum Crude to Rs. 8400 w.e.f. 1st May 2024

Central Govt raises Windfall Tax on Petroleum Crude from Rs. 6,800 to Rs. 9,600

Advantages

• Increases government revenue: The government can raise revenue in other areas thanks to the windfall tax.
• Decrease in Commodity: Commodities in limited supply in India may see a price decline. For example, fuel and diesel prices were reduced due to the windfall tax.
• Fair Contributions: Governments can ensure that these industries contribute their fair share to the nation’s economy by imposing windfall taxes on crude oil companies during periods of exceptional profitability.
• Overall industrial Developments: Encouraging investments in research and development, technological advancements, and infrastructure projects, the windfall taxes facilitate industry growth and contribute to overall economic progress.
• Price Regulation: Windfall taxes serve as a mechanism for regulating crude oil prices. By curbing excessive profits, these taxes contribute to price stability and ensure that essential commodities remain affordable for consumers.
• Improved Public Services: From the profits arising from the collection of windfall tax, the Government will equally distribute the wealth and invest the same for the improvement of public services, eventually benefitting the consumers, who designate the general population.

Disadvantages

The implementation of the windfall tax by the Government may lead to arbitrary taxation. businesses or industries cannot justifiably presume their pricing strategy, ultimately can lead to repulsion of the investors.

Imposition of windfall tax can also lead to competitive drawbacks. The countries without windfall tax enjoy a competitive advantage over countries with windfall tax. This is because the organizations or companies of the former countries will never run at a loss while experiencing an above-average profit.  

Conclusion

Windfall Tax is neither an absolute boon nor an unequivocal bane. It comes with its own set of pros and cons. However, it would be suggestible that the levy of windfall taxes should be done in moderation. 

A windfall tax is a tax that a government may impose or an additional tax that may be imposed on a business when it generates a sizable unanticipated profit, particularly if the company has benefited from favourable economic conditions.

Companies in specific economic sectors, that gain profit from circumstances like commodity shortages that significantly drive up the cost of the goods at the expense of consumers may be subject to windfall taxes. Depending on the source of the money and the law of the land, people may also be required to pay tax on a windfall.

Windfall taxes on crude oil companies in India have been debated for decades. While their implementation can have positive and negative effects on crude oil prices, windfall taxes are essential for ensuring fair contributions from profitable industries. By regulating prices, encouraging investment, and promoting economic stability, windfall taxes play a vital role in fostering sustainable economic growth and benefiting society.

Support our journalism by subscribing to Taxscan premium. Follow us on Telegram for quick updates