Property Buyers/Heirs from 2001 to Pay Higher Capital Gains Tax on Sale of Property due to Budget Impact: The End of Indexation Benefit

In the latest budget presented by the Finance Minister, a significant tax proposal has introduced a new dynamic to the property market, effectively creating two distinct classes among those intending to sell their properties.

This change is set to impact property sellers in varied ways depending on the purchase or inheritance date of their properties. Here’s an in-depth look at how the new rules will function and what they mean for property owners.

Key Changes in Long-Term Capital Gains (LTCG) Tax

The budget has made notable adjustments to the Long-Term Capital Gains (LTCG) tax rates applicable to property sales:

1. Reduction in LTCG Tax Rate: The Long Term Capital Gains tax rate has been reduced from 20% to 12.5% for all property sales, which is a substantial decrease aimed at encouraging transactions in the real estate market.

2. Indexation Benefit Changes: The benefit of indexation, which adjusts the property's value to reflect current market conditions, has seen critical amendments:

- For Properties Bought or Inherited on or After 2001: The indexation benefit has been entirely removed.

- For Properties Bought or Inherited Before 2001: The indexation benefit remains intact.

Implications of the Changes

Impact on Sellers of Pre-2001 Properties: For those selling properties bought or inherited before 2001, the budget changes offer both gains and losses. The gain comes in the form of a lower LTCG tax rate of 12.5%, down from 20%. However, the loss is seen in the discontinuation of the indexation benefit for properties acquired after 2001, which means that while the tax rate is lower, the calculation of gains may not reflect the inflation-adjusted market value increases as accurately.

Impact on Sellers of Post-2001 Properties: Those selling properties bought or inherited in 2001 or later will see a complete removal of the indexation benefit. Capital gains for these properties will now be calculated based solely on the difference between the actual purchase price and the sale price. However, the lower LTCG tax rate of 12.5% might offset some of the disadvantages of losing the indexation benefit.

How Indexation Previously Worked

Indexation for capital gains tax worked by adjusting the purchase price of the property to account for inflation, using April 2001 as the base year. For example, if an apartment was purchased before 2001, the property's value as of April 2001 would be used to determine its indexed price. This indexed price would then be subtracted from the sale price to calculate the capital gains, which would now be taxed at the reduced rate of 12.5%. However, properties bought after 2001 will no longer benefit from this adjustment, potentially increasing the taxable capital gain despite the lower tax rate.

Government's Justification and Industry Reactions

During the post-budget press conference, Finance Secretary TV Somanathan addressed concerns regarding the new tax rules. He assured that 95% of property sellers would not be adversely impacted by these changes. There is either a reduction or change in the effective rate of tax on property, he said, emphasising the simplicity and fairness of the new regime. We have a very simple regime — listed and unlisted assets are at 12.5% long-term and equities at 20%. The long-term rate has been rationalised, and it has not necessarily gone up, he added.

While the government positions these changes as beneficial, particularly with the lower tax rate, the removal of indexation for post-2001 properties is seen by some as a potential drawback, complicating the financial planning for many sellers. The real estate market is expected to closely monitor how these changes will influence property transactions and overall market dynamics in the coming months.

Conclusion

The 2024 budget tax proposal represents a significant shift in the way long-term capital gains from property sales are treated. By creating distinct classes based on the date of purchase or inheritance, the government aims to simplify the tax regime while also encouraging more real estate transactions. Property sellers need to carefully assess the impact of these changes on their financial planning to make informed decisions in the new tax environment.

Support our journalism by subscribing to Taxscan premium. Follow us on Telegram for quick updates