Cold Storage & Warehouse: Why “Tea” Isn’t Agricultural Produce Under GST

Tea is born in the soil. It is planted, nourished, and hand-picked from the estates that depend entirely on agricultural skills. But under the GST regime, the tea, at least in the form in which it is traded, does not qualify to be termed agricultural produce for the purpose of availing the exemption for cold storage and warehousing services. This differentiation, while seemingly trivial, has considerable tax implications.

The GST Act provides a valuable exemption for storage and warehousing services relating to agricultural produce. At first blush tea appears to qualify as an agricultural product given that it is grown on tea plantations.

Certain support services like loading, unloading, packing, storage, and warehousing of agricultural produce are exempted from taxation under GST. But this exemption is subject to a specific legal definition. “Agricultural produce” means goods that are produced through cultivation of plants or rearing of animals either without any processing or with such processing as may be necessary to make them marketable in their primary market without any processing that changes their essential characteristics.

Thus, the emphasis here is not merely on agricultural products but also on processing. There is a clear exemption for agricultural products but once processing sets in, even in their primary form the exemption may not hold.

However, the reality is that tea is not considered an agricultural product for the purposes of exemption for cold storage or warehouse services. The difference is not the cultivation but the processing.

In the context of the GST agricultural product is defined as an agricultural product that arises from the cultivation of plants on which no processing is carried out, or where processing is carried out to an extent that is merely incidental or normal processing that is carried out by the cultivator for the purpose of making the product marketable in the primary market.

The distinction is very relevant in the case of tea. Freshly plucked green tea leaves could conceivably qualify as agricultural produce. However, the tea that is actually sold at auctions, warehouses, to exporters, and in the market is not the fresh tea leaf at all.

It has been through a very detailed and scientifically controlled manufacturing process. The tea leaves are withered to dry them, rolled to rupture the cellular structure, oxidized to enhance the flavor and color, fired to dry the tea, and graded to standardize the product. These operations are conducted at specialized tea factories with specialized equipment.

There are various processes involved in the transformation of tea leaves after plucking, including withering, rolling, fermentation, drying, and grading.

In the interpretation of GST law the rule of transformation test is always followed. If the result of processing shows a new product with a different name character and use then the original identity of the commodity is not maintained.

The processing of tea fulfills the criteria of the three parameters. The essential character of the leaf changes and the commodity gets new attributes. The marketability of the commodity changes from the primary agricultural market to the commercial market.

These are not cleaning or basic preservation processes. These are manufacturing processes that result in the transformation of green tea leaves into an economically distinguishable product. The tea leaves that are sold or auctioned are not in their raw agricultural form.

Therefore, tea is considered a manufactured product rather than an agricultural product for the purposes of the GST. The exemption that is given for the provision of cold storage or any other services for the storage of raw agricultural products such as grains, pulses, or fresh fruits is not applicable.

READ MORE:How To CalculateInterest On a Personal Loan Using Simple And Practical Methods

Why This Classification Matters;

• The storage of processed tea is liable to GST and no exemption is provided.
• The GST compliance liability on such services must be clear to traders and warehouse operators.
• The level of processing rather than its agriculture determines its eligibility.
• It has greater industrial implications for pricing, contracts, and input tax credit planning.
• It is a further expression of the general principle that processing changes the tax treatment.

This classification holds important commercial implications for tea businesses and warehouses. It removes ambiguity on the fact that the taxability of tea is not dependent on whether it comes from the soil, but on the level of processing and marketability.

In GST law, transformation is an important factor and in the case of tea, this transformation changes everything.

Support our journalism by subscribing to Taxscan premium. Follow us on Telegram for quick updates