ICAI Certificate Issuance Checklist for CAs: Everything You Need

Have you ever found yourself unsure about how much detail is required when issuing a certificate for a client? Or questioned what your exact responsibilities are when signing off on a special-purpose report? That’s exactly where the ICAI Checklist for Issuance of Certificates proves invaluable.

This checklist article incorporates paragraph-specific references from the Guidance Note on Reports orCertificates for Special Purposes (Revised 2016) by ICAI, clearing up confusion and ensuring thoroughness.

When the Checklist Applies (Para 1-2)

The checklist applies to special-purpose assurance engagements, where you provide an opinion or conclusion to enhance credibility for specific users. Examples include:

• Turnover certificate for a government tender.
• Net worth certificate for visa or loan applications.
• Fund utilization certificate for regulatory compliance.

When the Checklist Doesn’t Apply (Para 9-11)

It does not apply to non-assurance services like tax return preparation, consulting, or internal advisory without an assurance component.

Practical Insight: Assurance vs. Advisory

Ask yourself: “Am I just presenting facts, or am I vouching for their credibility?”

Section A – Determining Applicability

Confirming Scope of Engagement

Before accepting, clarify:

• The engagement’s objective and subject matter.
• The intended users (e.g., bank, regulator).
• Whether assurance is required.

Initial Ethical and Independence Check

Per Para 17, ensure:

• Compliance with the ICAI Code of Ethics.
• Independence from the entity, documented in working papers.

Example: For a net worth certificate, confirm no financial interest in the client’s business.

Section B – Detailed Procedure Checklist

Step 1: Quality Control (Para 17)

Maintain strong quality controls at both the firm and engagement levels as per SQC 1.

Step 2: Preconditions & Acceptance (Para 18–23)

Verify:

• Ethical clearance and independence.
• Suitable subject matter and measurable criteria.
• Ability to obtain sufficient evidence.
• No scope limitations (decline if present).

Example: For a turnover certificate, ensure sales data is verifiable and criteria align with tender requirements.

Step 3: Setting Clear Objectives (Para 12–14)

Define whether you’re providing reasonable assurance (positive opinion) or limited assurance (negative conclusion)?

Don’t mix them without clarity. Give separate reporting if required.

Step 4: Skepticism & Judgment (Para 34–36)

Remain professionally skeptical, especially when:

• Evidence contradicts management’s claims ( for eg. unreported sales)
• There’s a history of misstatements
• Internal controls are weak (for eg. no segregation of duties).

Step 5: Planning the Engagement (Para 37–40)

Develop a plan covering:

• Scope, timeline, and procedures.
• Suitability of criteria.
• Risk-based allocation of responsibilities.

Reassess if preconditions are not met, potentially declining the engagement.

Step 6: Materiality & Testing (Para 41–50)

Set materiality thresholds (quantitative and qualitative) for both reasonable and limited assurance. Design procedures based on risk and materiality.

Example: A Rs. 10,000 error in a Rs. 10 crore turnover certificate may be immaterial, but a qualitative issue like fraud is always significant.

Step 7: Understanding the Subject Matter (Para 51–53)

Understand:

• Internal controls and systems for reasonable assurance.
• Data preparation processes for limited assurance.

Example: For a fund utilization certificate, review the vendor payment process and approval controls.

Step 8: Gathering Evidence (Para 54–57)

Collect sufficient, appropriate evidence via:

• Recalculation, reperformance, observation, or inquiry.
• Evaluate uncorrected misstatements and revise procedures if risks change.

Step 9: Use of Experts & Other Work (Para 58–61, 81)

When relying on experts (e.g., a valuer for assets) or internal auditors:

• Assess their competence and objectivity.
• Retain responsibility in the report.

Step 10: Report Format Requirements (Para 29–33, 82)

For prescribed formats:

• Include essential elements (Para 80).
• Attach a separate statement if the format lacks required details (Para 32A).
• Retain documentation if authorities reject the report.

Example: If a bank’s format omits the assurance basis, attach a statement clarifying compliance with the Guidance Note.

Step 11: Reviewing Subsequent Events (Para 67–68)

Look out for:

• Events that may alter conclusions (e.g., major expenses post-period)
• Legal issues or penalties

Perform necessary procedures and document everything.

Step 12: Identifying Fraud or Non-Compliance (Para 69–71)

If you spot suspicious transactions or non-compliance:

• Investigate further
• Communicate with management and those in charge
• Consider modifying your report

Step 13: Communicating with Governance (Para 72–74)

Report important issues:

• Discrepancies in documentation
• Delays in information
• Ethical lapses

Keep records of all communication, including minutes or emails.

Step 14: Written Representations (Para 62–66)

Obtain a signed management representation letter confirming:

• Responsibility for data accuracy.
• Compliance with laws.
• No known fraud or litigation. If refused, consider modifying the opinion or withdrawing.

Section C – Finalization and Completion

Structuring the Final Report (Para 75-80, 83-91)

Include:

• Title: “Independent Practitioner’s Report.”
• Specific addressee (not “To whomsoever it may concern”).
• Subject matter, criteria, limitations, responsibilities, procedures, opinion, signature, place, and date.
• Emphasis of Matter/Other Matter paragraphs to highlight issues without modifying the opinion (e.g., pending litigation uncertainty).
• Modify the report (qualified, adverse, or disclaimer) for material misstatements, scope limitations, or insufficient evidence (Para 83–91).

Example: A qualified opinion may be issued if management restricts access to bank statements for a turnover certificate.

Documentation Standards (Para 92-97)

Retain for 7 years: Engagement letter, working papers, management representations, and final certificate.

Tip: Use a cloud-based document management system for easy retrieval.

Summary Table with Paragraph References

Support our journalism by subscribing to Taxscan premium. Follow us on Telegram for quick updates