Inverted Duty Refund After Rule 89 Changes: Understanding the Formula and Frequent Disallowances

Inverted duty structure is a common GST problem for many Indian businesses. You pay GST at a higher rate on inputs, but you sell finished goods or services at a lower GST rate. Over time, input tax credit (ITC) keeps building up in your electronic credit ledger. GST law permits a refund of unutilised ITC in this situation, but only within the limits set by Section 54 and Rule 89.

Refund under inverted duty is not a full refund of your entire accumulated ITC. It is a formula-based refund. After changes in Rule 89, many taxpayers face partial sanction, rejection, or repeated deficiency memos. A clear understanding of the formula and the frequent disallowances will reduce disputes and speed up refunds.

1) What counts as inverted duty structure

Inverted duty structure exists when the GST rate on your inputs is higher than the GST rate on your output supplies. The output supply must be taxable. If your output is nil-rated or fully exempt, refund under inverted duty does not apply. Many errors start here because taxpayers mix exempt turnover with inverted turnover and claim refund on the full pool of ITC.

You must also check notifications that restrict refund for certain goods or services. If your outward supply falls under a notified restriction, refund is not allowed even if the rate on inputs is higher.

2) The big shift after Rule 89 changes

The most important change for inverted duty refund is the meaning of “Net ITC” in the formula.

Under the current rule design, Net ITC for inverted duty refund covers ITC on inputs during the relevant period. Refund on input services does not form part of Net ITC for the inverted duty formula. This single point explains a large part of refund reductions seen in practice.

Many businesses have high input service costs: rent, security, professional fees, freight, repair, marketing, job work, software subscriptions. Even when these services are used for taxable business, the inverted duty refund formula does not pick them up as Net ITC. The credit may remain in the ledger, but the refund amount stays lower.

This also creates a gap between “ledger balance” and “eligible refund.” Taxpayers often expect refund equal to accumulated credit. The officer applies the formula and sanctions a lower amount. That difference is not an error in processing. It is a built-in limit.

3) The formula

For inverted duty refund, the rule provides a “Maximum Refund Amount” based on turnover and Net ITC. The formula uses these moving parts:

• Turnover of inverted rated supply of goods and services

• Net ITC (inputs only) for the relevant period

• Adjusted total turnover for the relevant period

• Tax payable on such inverted rated supply, with a reduction factor linked to Net ITC and total ITC on inputs plus input services

The formula aims to refund ITC that relates to the inverted rated outward supplies, but it also reduces refund by the output tax that you already pay on those outward supplies.

What you must take away:

1. Refund moves with turnover. If sales drop, refund drops even if purchases stay high.

2. Refund moves with input ITC. If you buy less, refund drops.

3. Refund does not cover input services as Net ITC for inverted duty.

4. Refund has a reduction part linked to output tax and ratio factors.

A clean computation needs a clean segregation of turnover and ITC for the same tax period.

4) Step-by-step approach for computation

Step 1: Identify the relevant period.

Refund is filed for a tax period. You can club periods when the portal permits, but your working must stay period-wise. Each period must reconcile with returns.

Step 2: Compute turnover of inverted rated supplies.

Include only outward supplies where input rate is higher than output rate and the outward supply is taxable. Exclude exempt outward supplies. Exclude non-GST supplies.

Step 3: Compute adjusted total turnover.

This includes taxable supplies and zero-rated supplies, and it excludes exempt supplies. Errors here create inflated refund claims.

Step 4: Compute Net ITC for the period.

For inverted duty refund, Net ITC means ITC on inputs availed during the period. Do not add ITC on input services to Net ITC.

Step 5: Identify tax payable on inverted rated supplies.

This is the output GST liability on those outward supplies for the period.

Step 6: Apply the formula and match with ledger balance.

If the formula gives a lower amount than ledger balance, the difference will remain in the ledger.

5) Frequent disallowances and how to prevent them

Refund officers disallow claims for repeat patterns. Most of these come from classification mistakes, document gaps, or return mismatches.

A) Claim includes input services in Net ITC

This is the most common error. Taxpayer calculates Net ITC as total ITC (inputs + input services). Officer restricts Net ITC to inputs. The claim gets reduced and sometimes treated as incorrect computation.

Fix: Maintain a register that splits ITC on inputs and ITC on input services for each period. Use purchase ledger tags and GSTR-2B split.

B) Refund claimed on exempt or nil-rated outward supplies

Inverted duty refund does not apply when outward supply is nil-rated or fully exempt. Taxpayers sometimes include such supplies in “inverted turnover” or in adjusted turnover incorrectly.

Fix: Keep a supply-wise mapping: HSN/SAC, tax rate, exempt flag, and whether the supply qualifies as inverted for that period.

C) ITC blocked under Section 17(5)

Blocked credits get picked up during scrutiny. Common cases: motor vehicles, food and beverages, club memberships, personal consumption, works contract for immovable property, goods lost or destroyed.

Fix: Remove blocked credits from the refund computation set. Also reverse them in returns where required.

D) ITC not matching with GSTR-2B

Refund processing uses data checks. If ITC in your books does not match with GSTR-2B, the officer restricts eligible ITC and refund.

Fix: Ensure vendor compliance, follow-up for GSTR-1 filing by vendors, and claim ITC based on 2B discipline. Keep a monthly 2B reconciliation file.

E) ITC reversal not accounted

If you have reversals under Rule 42/43 (common credit, exempt supplies, capital goods reversal) or reversals for non-payment within the time limit, and you do not factor them, the refund claim becomes inflated.

Fix: Maintain a reversal tracker and link it with period-wise ITC eligible for refund.

F) Wrong adjusted total turnover

Taxpayers often reduce turnover by excluding taxable supplies or include exempt supplies by mistake. Either error changes the ratio and changes refund.

Fix: Start from GSTR-3B outward tax summary and GSTR-1 taxable value, then rebuild adjusted turnover with clear exclusions.

G) Wrong tax payable figure

Tax payable on inverted rated supplies must match outward liability for those supplies. If you use total output tax for all supplies, the reduction part of formula becomes wrong.

Fix: Keep a separate outward register for inverted rated supplies and compute output tax for only those supplies.

H) Wrong period selection and return filing gaps

Refund filing requires that relevant returns are filed. If GSTR-1 or GSTR-3B is pending for any period involved, the portal blocks filing or the officer issues deficiency memo.

Fix: File returns first, then refund. Maintain a checklist: GSTR-1, GSTR-3B, and other required filings for the claim period.

I) Invoices or statements not consistent with portal format

Refund requires statements and supporting documents. If your statement has invoice numbers that do not match returns or has date format errors, the officer issues a deficiency memo.

Fix: Prepare statement from the same dataset used for GSTR-1 and books, then validate invoice counts, taxable value, and tax.

6) A practical checklist before you file RFD-01

• Confirm outward supplies qualify as inverted rated and are taxable.

• Confirm no notified restriction applies to your outward supplies.

• Reconcile ITC with GSTR-2B for the period.

• Split ITC into inputs and input services. Use only inputs for Net ITC.

• Ensure Rule 42/43 reversals and other reversals are reflected.

• Build adjusted total turnover with correct exclusions.

• Ensure GSTR-1 and GSTR-3B for the period are filed and match your statement.

• Keep a working paper that links each number in the formula to a return line or ledger report.

7) What to expect during scrutiny

In inverted duty refunds, officers focus on three things: eligibility of the outward supply, eligibility of ITC, and correctness of the formula inputs. If your data set is clean, refund moves faster. If your claim is based on ledger balance instead of the formula, refund reduces and the officer issues an order for partial sanction.

Support our journalism by subscribing to Taxscan premium. Follow us on Telegram for quick updates