Time-Share Membership Fees Not Fully Taxable Under Income Tax Upfront: Madras HC Upholds Deferred Revenue Recognition in Mahindra Holidays Case [Read Order]

In a recent ruling, the Madras High Court held that time-share membership fees received upfront are not fully taxable under the Income Tax Act in the same year and it can be spread over the contract period because services are given for many years.

The case was filed by the Income Tax Department against Mahindra Holidays and Resorts (India) Ltd. for the assessment year 2003-04. The company runs a time-share business where members pay fees and get holiday stay every year for 25 or 33 years. The company showed 60% of the fee as income in that year and deferred 40% to future years.

The Assessing Officer did not accept this and said full amount should be taxed in the same year. The assessee appealed, and the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) allowed it. The ITAT also dismissed the Revenue appeal saying same issue was already decided earlier.

Before the High Court, the Revenue argued that full income arises at the time of receipt and there is no concept of deferred income in Income Tax Act. It also argued that maintenance and utility charges are collected separately, so the upfront fee is only for membership right.

The assessee’s counsel argued that the fee is not just for entry, but for long term services. It pointed out that the company must provide accommodation every year and even pay compensation if it fails, so it has real obligation.

The Division Bench of Justice G. Jayachandran and Justice Shamim Ahmed observed that the membership fee is linked with long term obligation and not just one time receipt. The court explained that the company has to provide services every year and this is not a contingent liability.

The court also pointed out that maintenance charges are separate and cannot be used to tax full fee upfront. The court observed that law allows income to be recognised over time when services are given for many years. It held that the assessee method is correct and shows real income.

The court dismissed the Revenue appeal and held that part of the membership fee can be deferred and taxed over the contract period.

Support our journalism by subscribing to Taxscan premium. Follow us on Telegram for quick updates